Weird article. Lots of good points about the actual subject of prole drift, especially on the "micro" level of day to day interactions, along the lines of what's been seen here before. But the sudden turn to glazing the Silicon Valley technocracy as though implying that resource-guzzling data centers and rocket acrobatics is going to be mankind's salvation is, to put it in the lingo of the Kids These Days, rather cringe.
Musk has always struck me as a master of showmanship who knows exactly how to put on a great performance to the applause of Investors and Important People, but the act has been wearing thin for a while now and he seems to be greatly reduced and approaching Sad Clown status. And the point about data center water consumption is largely a straw man; regardless of water, there's no denying the things consume extraordinary amounts of electricity and mineral resources (most notably copper, which is a vital resource set to skyrocket in price as extraction and production challenges mount; obligatory shoutout to @thehonestsorcerer who's covered this in detail) in the vain pursuit of summoning a Shiny Silicon God that will somehow pull us out of the great civilizational pit in which we are now trapped.
These far-fetched, utopian ambitions seem ridiculous to normal people who don't want to see their electricity bills soar when a data center with a footprint of a college campus is built down the road to the exclusive benefit of distant technocratic interests. A couple cherry-picked examples of dumb people reacting to data centers for dumb reasons doesn't tell much of the story at all. The real issue isn't visionaries on the cusp of turning Mankind into a glorious interstellar civilization being held back by drooling troglodytes; it's an industrial, world-spanning consumeristic civilization that has irresponsibly burnt through nonrenewable resources with no care for the consequences of the end of perpetual economic growth.
I don't know if Tucker Carlson was really attacked by a demon or whatever, but these kinds of accounts pull back the curtain of the Modern Enlightened Secular Society of the sort Richard Dawkins and Daniel Dennett would treat as a given. Modern Man has spent a very long time convincing himself that a couple centuries of learning about the natural world and engineering machines has banished the spiritual realm, but as an Orthodox Christian I find the materialist mindset to be little more than metaphysical myopia. I frequently hear anecdotes (in real life, as well) from people experiencing strange and unwelcome spiritual phenomena nowadays, and never heard anything of the sort 15-20 years ago. Sure, there is quackery and superstition out there as well, but it's not hard to get a sense that foul spiritual forces are operating with a greater level of boldness than in quite some time.
On the political front I doubt there are many who "whipped to the right in 2024 [and] whipped back to the left in 2026." The reason for the results of the midterms is not hard to explain: many people who enthusiastically supported Trump felt they had been totally betrayed, and simply stayed home, refusing to vote for candidates who had fooled them many times over promising to serve America and instead serving the agenda of a deranged, manipulative foreign state. On the other hand, the Left was energized and had various candidates they got excited about. The real culprit of this outcome isn't lazy voters on the Right, it's poor leadership and a dearth of compelling candidates.
Finally, I don't claim to be a Harry Potter expert by any means, but I'm struggling to see the hospital ward aesthetic here. The two versions of Hogwarts don't look identical, but I can recognize what it's supposed to be. The poor lighting and cinematography of modern film is much more egregious here than the set design.
Reading this was its own version of doom scrolling. I agreed with most of it though until I got to the defense of the biggest buffoon of them all - Trump. Don’t get me wrong, I voted for no Blue candidates but I would never ever defend him. It’s not so much what he did (in most cases). It’s how and why he did it. Take tariffs. The chaos of “liberation day”. Changing the target of the tariffs and the amount seemingly by the minute. Blowing up long term economic relationships in senseless ways. Or take the Iran war. It’s not like allowing Iran to have nuclear weapons was a good thing. It’s that it seems that he was motivated by his own personal reputation and had no plan to actually win it when he went in. He’s a buffoon.
Good post, though I’ve since given up on Trump and the right should make preparations for a Post-Trump America. Also, I agree at the beginning that vulgarization of Halloween, entertainment, society, etc. but this brings up a very good question:
What’s worse: Silification? Or Vulgarization? Tolkien & Lewis had the hot take of thinking vulgarization was not as bad as silification, but we must remember that they saw Disney with Snow White and an adaptation of Narnia, I think, which were incredibly silly and childish compared to their stories, especially Tolkien’s and the classic fairytales upon which they grew up reading.
Good points and arguments made, to be sure. But this portion: "Unable to stick with the “reindustrialize America and deport migrants” party because of gas prices" completely sweeps by what cause the gas prices--starting an ill-advised war as proxy state for that ill-begotten country over on the East end of the Mediterranean. That was a huge broken promise. Plenty of people before the election said this would lead to electoral disaster. Well...
Weird article. Lots of good points about the actual subject of prole drift, especially on the "micro" level of day to day interactions, along the lines of what's been seen here before. But the sudden turn to glazing the Silicon Valley technocracy as though implying that resource-guzzling data centers and rocket acrobatics is going to be mankind's salvation is, to put it in the lingo of the Kids These Days, rather cringe.
Musk has always struck me as a master of showmanship who knows exactly how to put on a great performance to the applause of Investors and Important People, but the act has been wearing thin for a while now and he seems to be greatly reduced and approaching Sad Clown status. And the point about data center water consumption is largely a straw man; regardless of water, there's no denying the things consume extraordinary amounts of electricity and mineral resources (most notably copper, which is a vital resource set to skyrocket in price as extraction and production challenges mount; obligatory shoutout to @thehonestsorcerer who's covered this in detail) in the vain pursuit of summoning a Shiny Silicon God that will somehow pull us out of the great civilizational pit in which we are now trapped.
These far-fetched, utopian ambitions seem ridiculous to normal people who don't want to see their electricity bills soar when a data center with a footprint of a college campus is built down the road to the exclusive benefit of distant technocratic interests. A couple cherry-picked examples of dumb people reacting to data centers for dumb reasons doesn't tell much of the story at all. The real issue isn't visionaries on the cusp of turning Mankind into a glorious interstellar civilization being held back by drooling troglodytes; it's an industrial, world-spanning consumeristic civilization that has irresponsibly burnt through nonrenewable resources with no care for the consequences of the end of perpetual economic growth.
I don't know if Tucker Carlson was really attacked by a demon or whatever, but these kinds of accounts pull back the curtain of the Modern Enlightened Secular Society of the sort Richard Dawkins and Daniel Dennett would treat as a given. Modern Man has spent a very long time convincing himself that a couple centuries of learning about the natural world and engineering machines has banished the spiritual realm, but as an Orthodox Christian I find the materialist mindset to be little more than metaphysical myopia. I frequently hear anecdotes (in real life, as well) from people experiencing strange and unwelcome spiritual phenomena nowadays, and never heard anything of the sort 15-20 years ago. Sure, there is quackery and superstition out there as well, but it's not hard to get a sense that foul spiritual forces are operating with a greater level of boldness than in quite some time.
On the political front I doubt there are many who "whipped to the right in 2024 [and] whipped back to the left in 2026." The reason for the results of the midterms is not hard to explain: many people who enthusiastically supported Trump felt they had been totally betrayed, and simply stayed home, refusing to vote for candidates who had fooled them many times over promising to serve America and instead serving the agenda of a deranged, manipulative foreign state. On the other hand, the Left was energized and had various candidates they got excited about. The real culprit of this outcome isn't lazy voters on the Right, it's poor leadership and a dearth of compelling candidates.
Finally, I don't claim to be a Harry Potter expert by any means, but I'm struggling to see the hospital ward aesthetic here. The two versions of Hogwarts don't look identical, but I can recognize what it's supposed to be. The poor lighting and cinematography of modern film is much more egregious here than the set design.
Reading this was its own version of doom scrolling. I agreed with most of it though until I got to the defense of the biggest buffoon of them all - Trump. Don’t get me wrong, I voted for no Blue candidates but I would never ever defend him. It’s not so much what he did (in most cases). It’s how and why he did it. Take tariffs. The chaos of “liberation day”. Changing the target of the tariffs and the amount seemingly by the minute. Blowing up long term economic relationships in senseless ways. Or take the Iran war. It’s not like allowing Iran to have nuclear weapons was a good thing. It’s that it seems that he was motivated by his own personal reputation and had no plan to actually win it when he went in. He’s a buffoon.
All non-God based civilizations die. All non-God based countries are destroyed.
People don't trust their government anymore. Nor do they trust technology since technology has cannibalized their jobs.
Good post, though I’ve since given up on Trump and the right should make preparations for a Post-Trump America. Also, I agree at the beginning that vulgarization of Halloween, entertainment, society, etc. but this brings up a very good question:
What’s worse: Silification? Or Vulgarization? Tolkien & Lewis had the hot take of thinking vulgarization was not as bad as silification, but we must remember that they saw Disney with Snow White and an adaptation of Narnia, I think, which were incredibly silly and childish compared to their stories, especially Tolkien’s and the classic fairytales upon which they grew up reading.
Thoughts to ponder.
Good points and arguments made, to be sure. But this portion: "Unable to stick with the “reindustrialize America and deport migrants” party because of gas prices" completely sweeps by what cause the gas prices--starting an ill-advised war as proxy state for that ill-begotten country over on the East end of the Mediterranean. That was a huge broken promise. Plenty of people before the election said this would lead to electoral disaster. Well...